Buyer's guide - Seiji McCarthy

American-Japanese bespoke shoemaker Seiji McCarthy has achieved great success with his merge of classic American style with precise, skilled Japanese craftsmanship. He offers MTO, MTM and bespoke at exceptional quality. Here’s a buyer’s guide to the brand with a pair of bespoke longwings I ordered as base.

 

About the brand

Seiji McCarthy grew up in Philadelphia with an American father and a Japanese mother. Before shoemaking, he had an international career which included working for the NBA and the Chinese Olympic Committee ahead of the 2008 Beijing Olympics. An encounter with Berluti shoes sparked an interest that eventually led him to change profession.

He took shoemaking courses and trained with makers in Europe, before a visit to Hiro Yanagimachi in Tokyo opened up another path. Hiro offered to help him develop his skills in Japan, and Seiji eventually established his business upstairs at the shoe store World Footwear Gallery, taking his first orders in 2016. Alongside Hiro, Yohei Fukuda has been another generous source of knowledge during these early years, and still is. More about this journey can be found in my first report on Seiji McCarthy written back in 2017.

Seiji McCarthy some ten years ago when he recently moved to Japan.

Seiji McCarthy some ten years ago when he recently had moved to Japan.

The shoes he made back then were quite different from those most people associate with his name today. They were dressier, with a more British-Japanese appearance. As I discussed with him in episode 25 of the Shoegazing Podcast about revamping a shoe brand, Seiji gradually realised that this wasn’t quite the footwear he wanted to make himself.

An early sample.

An early sample.

Interestingly, it was living in Japan that brought his American heritage more to the forefront. The Japanese interest in preserving and developing traditional American clothing and footwear helped him find a direction that felt more personal. Relaxed elegance became central to the brand, with familiar American styles being the foundation of the collection. Ever since I met him the first time a decade ago, that’s also how he has dressed himself, so when he moved in that direction it made perfect sense to me.

Longwing brogues, loafers and split toe derbies make this direction easy to recognise. There’s a natural connection to the shoes many associate with classic American clothing, while the shaping and detailing give Seiji’s work its own character. A lot of inspiration is also taken from old American vintage shoes, he’s a regular visitor to for example the Super 8 vintage shoe store which is in walking distance from his workshop.

One of the new samples made after Seiji McCarthy's revamp of the brand.

One of the new samples made after Seiji McCarthy’s revamp of the brand.

His approach is perhaps best understood as making shoes that feel comfortable in a wardrobe as well as on the feet. In an interview with LAST magazine, Seiji described wanting a more casual, friendly character in his footwear. Shell cordovan is a natural material for this direction, alongside suede and grain calf. These are shoes that work well with the texture and substance of classic American casual clothing. A large part of his production is shell cordovan shoes, his customer really favours this.

In 2021 he moved into his own atelier in the Harajuku area of Tokyo, marking another step in the development of the business. He’s still located in the same area, but now in a slightly larges space, with workshop on the bottom and showroom on the top floor. He works with a small team with in-house upper maker and bottom makers, it’s only if one order machines stitched outsoles that this is done at a different location.

 

Offerings and prices

Seiji McCarthy offers Made to Order, Made to Measure and full bespoke. The distinction concerns how the last and fit are approached, with fully handmade shoes available across the three services. At the time of writing this article (November 2026) lead times are approximately 24 months for MTO and MTM, and 36 months for bespoke. The prices listed below are also the current prices and may change in the future.

MTO
From 360,000 JPY (approximately €2,050 / $2,300), excluding tax of 10%. Shoes are made on a standard house last, without individual fit modifications. Hand lasted and hand welted, from price is with machine stitched outsole, can be made with handmade sole stitch at an upcharge. Lasted shoe trees are charged separately.

MTO version of a split toe derby with machine stitched outsole.

MTO version of a split toe derby with machine stitched outsole.

MTM
Starts from 390,000 JPY (approximately €2,200 / $2,500), excl. tax. This allows last modifications to accomodate the customer’s feet while retaining the house last as the foundation. Hand lasted and hand welted, also here the from price is with machine stitched outsole, and can be made with handmade sole stitch at an upcharge. Lasted shoe trees charged separately.

Bespoke
From 680,000 JPY (approximately €3,900 / $4,300), excl. tax. Traditional full bespoke, where the last is developed for the individual customer, with at least one trial fitting being part of the process. As always leather and other specifications can affect the final price. Here lasted shoe trees are included in the price, and they are fully handmade as standard also sole stitching.

Fully handmade version of the split toe.

Fully handmade version of the split toe.

 

Order process

For enquiries and appointments, best is to contact Seiji on info@seijimccarthy.com before visiting him in Tokyo. He has done a few trunk shows overseas for example in the US, but given how busy he is I believe it’s not something I expect being common the coming years.

I’ve been visiting Tokyo regularly since many years, and I ordered my pair three years ago in autumn 2023. A style I didn’t own was a casual longwing brogue, and since I’ve admired Seiji McCarthy’s version for a long time, I decided to place an order with him. Given I have a bit special and sensitive feet, I went the bespoke route.

Longwing with storm welt in burgundy cordovan.

Longwing with storm welt in burgundy cordovan. Picture: Seiji McCarthy

After a quite extensive measurement process, we looked at the specs. I initially wanted the base model to be just as some versions I’ve seen from him with 360° storm welt, but with a rubber heel and rubber topy to work fine also during harsher weather. Material-wise, I actually did contemplate a burgundy shell cordovan pair, it would look lovely but since I’m not the biggest fan of how cordovan feel I went with a brown Annonay alpine grain leather.

Picture from the first fitting.

Picture from the first fitting.

A year later when I was back in Japan, we had a first fitting. There was some work to be done on the lasts, especially the toe box was too low for my big toes. A while after the fitting, Seiji reached out and suggested some changes. Firstly, he wanted to change the pattern. His longwing has had Florsheim’s legendary Kenmoor model as inspiration. Given how wide my feet are, he thought another vintage longwing made by the defunct company E.T. Wright would be more suitable. He also suggested to skip the storm welt since it makes the edge wider and enhancing the wide look, and instead go with a regular 360° welt.

Old vintage shoes, Florsheim Imperial Kenmoor to the left, E.T. Wright's longwing to the right. You can see how my first fitting above resembled the Florsheim but then was switched from second fitting to the E.T. Wright version as base.

Old vintage shoes that Seiji has, Florsheim Imperial Kenmoor to the left, E.T. Wright’s longwing to the right. You can see how my first fitting above resembled the Florsheim but then was switched from second fitting to the E.T. Wright version as base.

Honestly I was a bit sceptical at first, especially towards skipping the storm welt. I’ve always thought that longwings look best with storm welts. But I decided to trust Seiji’s judgement here. At the next fitting in autumn 2025 he had done the new pattern and here he surely was right, it looked like it would come out really nice. For the fit there was some smaller things to fix but no big issues left.

At the second fitting only small tweaks remained to be done on the lasts.

At the second fitting only small tweaks remained to be done on the lasts.

Fitting shoes is a good way for an apprentice or newer employee to train on making.

Fitting shoes is a good way for an apprentice or newer employee to train on making.

My lasts.

My lasts.

After cutting open the shoes some areas are examined again.

After cutting open the shoes some areas are examined again.

 

Final results

When I did my yearly Tokyo trip now in October, it was time to pick up the finished pair. Luckily I saw immediately that Seiji had been right with the choices of pattern and no storm welt, especially when I tried them on and could see how they looked on the feet. I think they could have come out really well also with a storm welt, but it would have a more chunky feel, perhaps too chunky with the width of the last. The shoes now are literally gorgeous, and very well-balanced.

Lovely longwings.

Lovely longwings.

Tanneries d'Annonay alpine grain up-close.

Tanneries d’Annonay alpine grain up-close.

Bottom.

Bottom.

Fit is pretty much spot on. Only small things have been when breaking them in they rubbed a tiny bit at the inner top line at first before leather softened up, and if I could have chosen I would have had the regular thin foam cushioning at the back under the sock lining (this goes out to all bespoke shoemakers out there, do ask your customers what they prefer, thin foam cushioning or no thin cushioning, since it’s really a personal preference thing).

As expected the making is of the highest level. Clean, sharp, distinct. Things like the straight breast and the single small hole instead of standard double between the large in the brogue pattern, brought from the E.T. Wright version, are small things to appreciate. Also always a treat to see perfectly levelled transitions between leather sole, rubber topy and metal toe tap.

The sweeping lines of a longwing derby is hard not to appreciate.

The sweeping lines of a longwing derby is hard not to appreciate.

Distinctly marked welt with well-executed sole stitching.

Distinctly marked welt with well-executed sole stitching.

Straight breast.

Straight heel breast.

Transition between the leather outsole and rubber topy is barely visible from the side.

Transition between the leather outsole and rubber topy is barely visible from the side.

From this angle one can see that the lasts are pretty wide.

From this angle one can see that the lasts are pretty wide.

I’ve been wearing the shoes a lot the past month. With the grain leather in the muted brown colour it’s a perfect autumn shoe. They will no doubt see much wear especially during the autumn and spring periods going forward. If you’re someone who appreciate the traditional American shoe styles but want more in terms of constructions, materials and perhaps also fit than the factory-made stuff available, Seiji McCarthy is a blessing.

Finish off with a bunch of more photos of the finished shoes.

Finish off with a bunch of more photos of the finished shoes.

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy

Seiji McCarthy